Why prevention matters
In the Pacific Northwest, a freshly cleaned roof is an invitation. The same damp, shaded conditions that grew the moss the first time are still there. Without some kind of treatment, the moss comes back, and you're paying for the same cleaning again.
There are several ways to stop that from happening. They are not equally good.
Zinc powder
Zinc is very effective at keeping moss from returning year to year, and it costs less than the alternatives. We think it's the best value of any option, which is why it's what we use.
- Effective
- Yes
- Cost
- Lower
- Downside
- None that outweighs the benefit
Bleach (sodium hypochlorite)
Sodium hypochlorite is ordinary household bleach, and it does kill moss. The trouble is that it kills everything else too. Using it is like dropping a bomb on your roof and whatever is around it: anything that can grow, won't. It's also the expensive way to do it.
- Effective
- Yes
- Cost
- High
- Downside
- Kills plants and anything else it reaches
Laundry detergent and baking soda
You'll see both recommended online. They can work, but only in high quantities. That's true of almost anything: use enough of any chemical and it will kill moss. In the amounts a person would reasonably put on a roof, they don't do the job.
- Effective
- Only in large amounts
- Cost
- Adds up quickly
- Downside
- Unreliable at sensible quantities
The best of both worlds
Bleach is effective but harsh and costly. Household products are gentle but don't work in reasonable amounts. Zinc powder gets you the effectiveness without the collateral damage, and at a lower price. That's the trade we recommend to our own customers.
Treatment only works on a clean roof
Prevention keeps new moss from taking hold. It isn't a substitute for removing moss that's already grown into a roof, because that moss is already doing its damage. The right order is: clean first, then treat.